America’s Test Kitchen’s Banana Bread Recipe Is *Definitely* Extra, but Is It Worth the Fuss? (2024)

  • Recipes
  • Breads

Recipe Review

Patty Catalano

Patty Catalano

Patty is a recipe developer and food writer. She worked Alton Brown’s Research Coordinator and podcast producer and in the Oxmoor House test kitchen. She loves maple syrup, coffee and board games. Patty lives in Atlanta with her husband and two children.

updated Jan 21, 2020

We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.

America’s Test Kitchen’s Banana Bread Recipe Is *Definitely* Extra, but Is It Worth the Fuss? (1)

America’s Test Kitchen is known for its meticulous dissection of classic American recipes, and their banana bread recipe is certainly no exception. Their cooks left no crumb unturned in their quest for the ultimate banana bread, managing to turn the humble breakfast treat into a multi-step affair that dirties a lot of dishes. I took to the kitchen to find out whether the extra effort was worth it.

How to Make America’s Test Kitchen’s Banana Bread

It takes just one glance to realize this recipe is unlike any other. You’ll start by microwaving five large, very ripe bananas for five minutes. You’ll then strain the cooked bananas, stirring to push all the moisture out of the fruit. After about 15 minutes, you should be left with a milky banana liquid.

Transfer the liquid to a small saucepan and simmer until syrupy. Combine the banana syrup and mashed, cooked bananas in a large bowl and whisk in brown sugar, eggs, melted butter, and vanilla extract. Whisk flour, baking soda, salt, and cinnamon in a separate bowl, then gradually add the dry ingredients to the wet mixture until just combined. Stir in toasted pecans, if desired. Transfer the batter to a standard loaf pan and sprinkle the top with coarse turbinado sugar. Bake until deeply browned and a cake tester comes out clean.

My Honest Review of America’s Test Kitchen’s Banana Bread

In all honesty, I’m conflicted about this banana bread. On one hand, this is what banana bread tastes like. It has a rich banana flavor, a tender crumb, holds a nice slice without crumbling, and gets even better when toasted the next day. The contrasting crunchy sugar topping had me in banana bread nirvana. That is, until I looked at the pile of dishes in my sink.

This recipe calls for the most bananas of the bunch, so you know the bread will be full of flavor with a squishy (in a good way!) texture. But while cooking, mashing, straining, and reducing the bananas does extract flavor (and is a smart strategy for underripe bananas), it isn’t necessary if your bananas are adequately freckled, because their sugars are already intensely concentrated. There wasn’t a significant enough difference in banana flavor to justify the time and dishes required for this step.

ATK leaves the addition of pecans optional, but I added them to get the full experience of the bread. However, the crown jewel of this bread is the crunchy sugar topping, which I’m now convinced no banana bread should be without.

If You Make America’s Test Kitchen’s Banana Bread

  1. Choose your bananas wisely. Five large, very ripe bananas are essential to the moist texture and bold banana flavor of this bread. Wait to make the bread until they are mottled with spots and release an intoxicatingly sweet aroma.
  2. Skip right over the complicated banana reduction. If you start with very ripe, sweet bananas you can skip right over the most complicated part of this recipe without any significant difference in flavor or texture.
  3. Consider the turbinado topping essential. You must top this bread with turbinado sugar. If you don’t have any on hand, a sprinkle of granulated sugar is the next best thing.

Overall rating: 6/10

America’s Test Kitchen’s banana bread is full of sweet banana flavor and capped with a crunchy crust that makes the extra effort almost worth it. In the end, the extra steps and dirty dishes make this recipe too complicated and time-consuming for me to consider making again.

Have you ever made America’s Test Kitchen’s Banana Bread? Tell us what you thought!

Read More About This Banana Bread Showdown

  • We Tested 4 Famous Banana Bread Recipes and Did *Not* Expect These Results
  • Why I Wasn’t Smitten with Smitten Kitchen’s Banana Bread
  • The Best-Ever Banana Bread Is from This Cult-Favorite Bakery
  • We Made Chrissy Teigen’s Viral Banana Bread Recipe. Here’s How It Compares.

Filed in:

baked goods

Baking

Bread

Breakfast

Recipe Review

Cooking Methods

America’s Test Kitchen’s Banana Bread Recipe Is *Definitely* Extra, but Is It Worth the Fuss? (2024)

FAQs

America’s Test Kitchen’s Banana Bread Recipe Is *Definitely* Extra, but Is It Worth the Fuss? ›

America's Test Kitchen's banana bread is full of sweet banana flavor and capped with a crunchy crust that makes the extra effort almost worth it. In the end, the extra steps and dirty dishes make this recipe too complicated and time-consuming for me to consider making again.

Why is banana bread bad? ›

You may find banana bread delicious, but conventional banana breads tend to be high in added sugar, refined carbs, and calories. Thus, it's best to enjoy banana bread occasionally as part of a balanced, nutrient-dense diet.

Why are older bananas better for banana bread? ›

Ripe bananas are not only softer and easier to mash and blend into a batter, but they are also sweeter, which is why baking recipes specifically call for ripe bananas in ingredient lists. As the bananas ripen, the fruit converts starches to sugars, making them sweeter and more flavorful.

How long does banana bread last unrefrigerated? ›

First, How Long Does Banana Bread Last? Wrapped well and stored at room temperature, banana bread will last about five days. If stored in the fridge, it should last a full week. A frozen loaf of banana bread will last up to a year in the freezer, wrapped well with storage wrap and aluminum foil.

Why does my banana bread not taste good? ›

Using too much butter makes for a heavier cake with less banana flavor. Using double the amount of butter that the recipe called for left me with a loaf that was dry on the outside and moist on the inside.

At what point should you not use bananas for banana bread? ›

If black bananas are spotted with mold, then it's time to step away! You absolutely should not use them for banana bread or consume them at all.

What happens when you put too much banana in banana bread? ›

Banana bread recipes typically ask you to use overripe bananas so that they're easier to mush. This means it's tempting to toss all your bananas into the mix when you're ready to bake, to avoid food waste. But if you add too much of the fruit into your batter, your bread could turn out mushy, heavy, and wet.

Can you use really old bananas for banana bread? ›

Brown, overripe bananas are sweeter because in the ripening process the starches in the banana are converted to sugar. You can even use super-soft, black bananas that have a really strong smell and are oozy inside. As long as they're not moldy, there's no such thing as too-ripe bananas for banana bread.

Why are older bananas better for you? ›

“Very ripe and overripe bananas are rich in flavor and antioxidants, which can help benefit our immune systems,” says Gabriel. “They also take less time to digest, which can be beneficial, depending on the person.” This phase is also where bananas become just right for adding sweetness and heft to smoothies and shakes.

Can you speed up ripening bananas for banana bread? ›

In order to speed up the ripening process, all you need to do is trap the ethene gas in with the banana by putting them in a paper bag – fruit gives off moisture, so you must use a bag that won't trap moisture. Ripening in a bag usually takes a day or so, but can be as speedy as overnight – just keep checking.

Should banana bread be refrigerated after baking? ›

Le says refrigerating banana bread will inhibit the growth of mold that can occur at room temperature and will increase its shelf life by up to a week.

Should you keep banana bread in the fridge or pantry? ›

Never store it in the refrigerator. A refrigerator circulates cool air, which removes moisture and can prematurely dry breads and cakes. Place your cooled loaf on a plate and cover it in plastic wrap, or store it in an airtight container. Store it for up to four days on your counter.

Should you refrigerate banana bread? ›

The best way to store banana bread is at room temperature in an airtight container. Though it will only stay fresh for about four days on the counter, this will keep your banana bread tasting the freshest.

Why does my banana bread not taste like banana bread? ›

Some banana bread just isn't strong in banana flavor. This is especially true if you make the mistake of not using overly ripe bananas for your recipe.

Why doesnt my banana bread taste like banana? ›

If your banana bread doesn't taste like bananas, it could be that you didn't use bananas that were ripe enough. The flavour of a ripe banana is quite different than a green banana. Choose the ripest bananas possible. Some bakers recommend using bananas that are on the verge of over-ripe with completely black peels.

Why is my banana bread so mushy in the middle? ›

Using a lot of bananas adds excess moisture, and there are two ways to get rid of it. You could either add more flour or increase the baking time.

Is banana bread healthier than white bread? ›

Healthier Fats: Many traditional bread recipes include unhealthy fats, such as saturated or trans fats, which can be detrimental to heart health. Banana bread can be prepared with healthier fat options, such as unsaturated fats from sources like nuts, seeds, or olive oil.

Why is banana bread so addictive? ›

Even sight or smell of food triggers a response in the brain's reward system. All foods are not equal, however, with the strongest hedonic response for the combination of sugar and fat. We have innate preference for sweet foods, which elicit a response as potent as that triggered by cocaine.

Why is banana bread not cake? ›

First, the obvious: Bread usually doesn't have icing or frosting like cake often does. Then, the less obvious: Banana bread can incorporate heavier flours, like all-purpose flour and whole wheat flour, while banana cake sometimes calls for pastry flour or cake flour, which is lighter.

Is banana bread good when you're sick? ›

Banana bread: This classic baked treat is easy to digest and can be made with simple, wholesome ingredients. Ginger snaps: Ginger has anti-inflammatory properties that may help to soothe an upset stomach, and these cookies are easy to make and store well.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 6035

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (68 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Birthday: 1996-12-09

Address: Apt. 141 1406 Mitch Summit, New Teganshire, UT 82655-0699

Phone: +2296092334654

Job: Technology Architect

Hobby: Snowboarding, Scouting, Foreign language learning, Dowsing, Baton twirling, Sculpting, Cabaret

Introduction: My name is Francesca Jacobs Ret, I am a innocent, super, beautiful, charming, lucky, gentle, clever person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.